Fig. 1 is a planning sketch for a community health centre in Muscat, where summer cooling creates a large demand for electricity. The local authority is com...

Assessment: Geography 9230 | Paper 2 Mock 01 | Written Paper 2 Subject: Geography - 9230

Question 1 Report

9230-p2-muscat-health-centre

Fig. 1 is a planning sketch for a community health centre in Muscat, where summer cooling creates a large demand for electricity. The local authority is comparing this proposed building with older public buildings that rely on air-conditioning throughout the day. Its design combines rooftop photovoltaic panels, deep external screens and vents that allow hot air to leave near the roof. A planted courtyard provides shade and reduces the amount of dark surface that absorbs energy. The centre will serve a new urban development, and planners want its electricity consumption to be lower without reducing access to healthcare. Renewable energy generation is especially useful because peak sunshine occurs during the hottest part of the day.

solar panelsshade screenhot-air ventshaded courtyard© EAGLE BEACON GLOBAL

Fig. 1 Proposed low-energy health centre.

(a) Identify the renewable energy source used by the panels. [1]
(b) Describe two design features in Fig. 1 that can reduce the need for air-conditioning. [2]
(c) Explain why the authority should include both energy-saving design and renewable energy in this urban project. [4]

Answer Details

(a) The panels use solar energy (sunlight). Photovoltaic panels convert energy from sunlight into electricity. [1]

(b) This tests how building design can reduce heat entering or remaining in a building, so less mechanical cooling is needed. Two valid descriptions are:

  • Deep external shade screens block direct sunlight from reaching windows and walls, reducing solar heating of the building. [1]
  • Hot-air vents allow warm air to escape near the roof. As hot air rises, the vents remove it and help keep indoor spaces cooler. [1]

The planted courtyard providing shade, and roof panels shading part of the roof, are also acceptable features. Any two well-described features gain the two marks.

(c) Energy-saving design reduces the amount of electricity the centre needs, while renewable energy supplies some electricity with a lower environmental impact. A complete explanation can include four linked points:

  1. Screens, courtyard shade and ventilation reduce heat gain and allow hot air to leave, so less electricity is needed for cooling. [1]
  2. The photovoltaic panels generate electricity from sunlight without burning fossil fuels. [1]
  3. Sunshine is strongest during the hottest part of the day, when demand for cooling is greatest, so solar generation is particularly well matched to the centre's electricity demand. [1]
  4. Using less fossil-fuel electricity reduces carbon dioxide emissions, helping make the urban development more sustainable. [1]

Further valid benefits include lower operating costs over time, improved energy security in a growing city, and demonstrating sustainable development in a public building. The key distinction is that saving energy reduces demand, whereas solar panels provide a renewable supply: combining both has a greater effect than using either one alone.

Download The App On Google Playstore

Everything you need to excel in your exams

Green Bridge CBT Mobile App
Personalized AI Learning Chat Assistant
200,000+ Exam Questions Across IGCSE, JAMB, WAEC & NECO
Over 3,900 Lesson Notes
Offline Support - Learn Anytime, Anywhere
Green Bridge Timetable
Literature Summaries & Potential Questions
Track Your Performance & Progress
In-depth Explanations for Comprehensive Learning