Question 1 Report
Fig 10 shows a portable workbench designed for use on building sites.
(a) The frame corners are joined using MIG welding.
(i) Describe the MIG welding process used to join the steel tubes at each corner of the frame. [4]
(ii) Give two advantages of using MIG welding over brazing for joining these steel tubes. [2]
(b) The clamping system uses a first-class lever.
(i) With the aid of a labelled sketch, explain how the lever mechanism provides a mechanical advantage when clamping a workpiece. [4]
(ii) Explain why increasing the length of the lever arm would make clamping easier for the user. [2]
(c) The folding version requires a pivot joint at each leg.
(i) Name and describe a suitable permanent mechanical joint that allows each leg to rotate against the frame. [2]
(ii) Sketch a locking device that holds each leg rigidly in the open position during use. [3]
(d) The steel tubes need protection from corrosion in outdoor conditions.
(i) Give two methods of protecting the steel frame from corrosion. [2]
(ii) For one method you identified in (d)(i), explain why it is particularly suitable for a workbench used on building sites. [2]
(e) The manufacturer considers using aluminium alloy tube instead of steel for the main frame.
Give two advantages and two disadvantages of aluminium alloy compared to steel for this product. [4]
(a)(i) Description of MIG welding for joining the steel tubes at each corner: [4]
(a)(ii) Two advantages of MIG welding over brazing for these steel tubes: [2]
(b)(i) The clamping system uses a first-class lever, where the fulcrum (pivot) is positioned between the effort (applied by the user's hand) and the load (the clamping force on the workpiece).
The sketch shows: the fulcrum/pivot positioned between the effort and the load [1]; effort applied by the user's hand at one end of the lever arm [1]; the clamping load acting on the jaw and workpiece at the other end [1]. Because the effort arm (fulcrum to hand) is longer than the load arm (fulcrum to jaw), the force applied to the workpiece is multiplied. This is the principle of mechanical advantage: a small effort over a large distance produces a large force over a small distance. [1]
(b)(ii) Increasing the length of the lever arm increases the distance from the point where the user applies effort to the fulcrum. [1] Since mechanical advantage equals the effort arm length divided by the load arm length (\( MA = \frac{\text{effort arm}}{\text{load arm}} \)), a longer effort arm means a greater mechanical advantage. The user can therefore apply a larger clamping force to the workpiece for the same physical effort, making clamping easier. [1]
(c)(i) A suitable permanent mechanical joint is a bolt (or clevis pin) acting as a pivot. A bolt passes through aligned holes in a bracket welded to the frame and a lug attached to the leg. [1] This allows the leg to rotate freely about the bolt axis while keeping the leg permanently attached to the frame. The bolt is secured with a nut or split pin to prevent it from working loose. [1]
(c)(ii) A locking device to hold each leg rigidly in the open position:
The sketch shows: a toggle clamp / over-centre latch mechanism that engages when the leg reaches its fully open position [1]; a stop plate or shoulder on the frame that prevents the leg from rotating past 90 degrees [1]; both the locked position (latch engaged, leg rigid) and the released position (latch lifted, leg free to fold) are indicated [1].
(d)(i) Two methods of protecting the steel frame from corrosion: [2]
(d)(ii) Galvanising is particularly suitable for a workbench used on building sites because the zinc layer provides sacrificial protection. [1] Even if the surface is scratched, chipped, or dented during rough handling on site, the zinc corrodes preferentially to the steel underneath (because zinc is more reactive), continuing to protect the exposed steel from rusting. This self-healing protection is critical for equipment subjected to heavy wear. [1]
(e) Advantages and disadvantages of aluminium alloy compared to steel: [4]
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Aluminium alloy is lighter (lower density, approximately one-third the density of steel), making the workbench easier to carry to different locations on site. [1] | Aluminium alloy is more expensive than mild steel, increasing the manufacturing cost of the product. [1] |
| Aluminium alloy has good natural corrosion resistance due to its self-forming oxide layer, reducing or eliminating the need for protective coatings like galvanising or painting. [1] | Aluminium alloy has a lower stiffness (lower Young's modulus), so the frame may flex more under heavy clamping loads or when supporting heavy workpieces, reducing stability. [1] |
Everything you need to excel in your exams