Question 1 Report
A school receptionist needs a notice board outside the main entrance where parents can read messages about events and term dates. The current notices are pinned to an uncovered board and become unreadable after heavy rain. Fig 1 shows the brick wall beside the main entrance of a school. Design a notice board with weather protection for a school entrance that keeps printed notices dry and readable in all seasons.
(a) List four additional points about the function of such a notice board with weather protection for a school entrance that you consider to be important. [4]
(b) Use sketches and notes to show two different hinge arrangements that would allow the cover to open for changing notices. [4]
(c) Develop and sketch three ideas for the notice board with weather protection for a school entrance. [12]
(d) Evaluate your ideas and justify why you have chosen one idea to develop more fully. [8]
(e) Draw, using a method of your own choice, a full solution to the problem. Include construction details and major dimensions. [12]
(f) Suggest suitable specific materials for your solution and give reasons for your choice. [4]
(g) Outline a method used to manufacture one part of your solution in the school workshop. [6]
[Total: 50]
(a) Four functional points [4 marks]
(b) Two hinge arrangements [4 marks]
Arrangement 1 — Top-hinged cover with gas strut stay: The transparent cover is hinged along its top edge, swinging upward to open. A gas strut (similar to those on car boot lids) holds the cover open at approximately 90 degrees while staff change notices, preventing it from falling shut. The top-hinge design means rainwater runs off the closed cover naturally, as the hinge is at the highest point. [2]
Arrangement 2 — Side-hinged cover (door style) with magnetic catch: The cover is hinged on one side using two butt hinges, opening like a door. A magnetic catch on the opposite side holds the cover closed when the lock is not engaged. This arrangement provides full access to the notice area from one side, making it easy to reach all corners. A rubber seal runs around the frame to prevent water ingress when closed. [2]
(c) Three design ideas [12 marks]
Idea 1 — Framed box with top-hinged acrylic cover and rubber seal: A rectangular timber or aluminium frame (700 mm x 550 mm x 50 mm deep) encloses a cork-backed display area. A 3 mm acrylic sheet is hinged along the top edge and sealed around the remaining three edges with EPDM rubber strip when closed. A cam lock at the bottom secures the cover. A gas strut holds the cover open for changing notices. The frame is powder-coated for weather resistance and mounted on the wall with concealed brackets. [4]
Idea 2 — Curved-front unit with sliding panel: A wall-mounted case with a curved clear polycarbonate front panel that slides sideways along top and bottom tracks to open. The curved profile sheds rainwater effectively and gives a modern appearance. The sliding mechanism avoids the need for space in front for a hinged door to swing open. The tracks must be precisely aligned to prevent jamming, which adds manufacturing complexity. [4]
Idea 3 — Double-door cabinet with central meeting edge: Two glazed panels, hinged on opposite sides, meet in the centre with a magnetic catch and overlapping lip. A key lock at the meeting edge secures both doors. This design provides wide access to the full notice area by opening both doors simultaneously. A felt or rubber seal runs around the frame perimeter. The double-door arrangement requires two sets of hinges and precise alignment at the central meeting point. [4]
(d) Evaluation and justification [8 marks]
Idea 1 (Top-hinged box) — Strengths: the top hinge positions the seal at the sides and bottom, where driving rain is more likely to enter than at the top; the gas strut holds the cover open hands-free; simple rectangular construction. Weaknesses: the cover, when open, projects above the board and may catch wind.
Idea 2 (Sliding panel) — Strengths: no door swing; curved profile sheds rain well. Weaknesses: sliding tracks are difficult to manufacture accurately and can jam or accumulate debris; the curved polycarbonate is harder to source than flat sheet.
Idea 3 (Double doors) — Strengths: wide access. Weaknesses: the central meeting edge is the weakest point for water ingress; two sets of hinges add cost and weight; alignment of the overlapping lip is critical.
Chosen idea: Idea 1. The top-hinged framed box provides the best combination of weather sealing (the hinge at the top ensures rain runs off the closed surface naturally), ease of access (the gas strut holds the cover open hands-free), and simplicity of construction (a rectangular frame with one set of hinges). The cam lock at the bottom is easy to operate and secure. [8]
(e) Full solution — construction details [12 marks]
The solution is drawn in isometric projection with a cross-section through the seal and a detail of the cover in its open position.
(f) Materials [4 marks]
(g) Manufacturing the frame [6 marks]
Everything you need to excel in your exams