Orchard Frame Works makes wooden display stands for independent retailers. Its manager has been offered a laser cutter costing $48 000. The new machine coul...

Assessment: Commerce 4CM1 | Paper 2 Mock 01 | Written Paper 2 Subject: Commerce - 4CM1

Question 1 Report

Orchard Frame Works makes wooden display stands for independent retailers. Its manager has been offered a laser cutter costing $48 000. The new machine could produce more accurate products and may help the business accept larger orders. Fig. 1 summarises three finance options discussed at a meeting. The firm has retained profit of $15 000 from last year, but the manager does not want to use all of this cash because timber prices can change. A bank has offered a loan, while an equipment company has offered to lease the cutter for monthly payments.

$48 000 laser cutterfinance neededRetained profit$15 000 availableBank loaninterest chargedLeasemonthly payment© EAGLE BEACON GLOBAL
Fig. 1

(a) Which one of the following is internal finance for Orchard Frame Works? Select one answer.
A a bank loan
B retained profit
C a lease from an equipment company
D credit from a supplier [2]

(b) Define the term leasing. [3]

(c) Explain why retained profit alone cannot pay for the new laser cutter. [4]

(d) Compare a bank loan with leasing as options for obtaining and using the machine. [5]

(e) Suggest which finance option, or combination of options, the manager should select. Give reasons for your answer. [6]

Answer Details

(a) The internal source of finance is retained profit. [2] It is money generated and kept by Orchard Frame Works, unlike a bank loan, leasing or supplier credit, which come from outside the business.

(b) Leasing is an agreement to use an asset owned by another business [1] in return for regular payments. [1] The user does not normally buy or own the asset at the start. [1]

(c) Retained profit is $15 000, [1] but the laser cutter costs $48 000. [1] Therefore:

\[\$48\,000-\$15\,000=\$33\,000\]

There is a $33 000 shortfall. [1] Using all retained profit would also remove the cash reserve needed if timber prices change or other expenses arise. [1]

(d) A bank loan provides borrowed money from a bank, [1] allowing Orchard Frame Works to buy and own the cutter. [1] Leasing permits use of a cutter that remains owned by the leasing company, [1] in return for monthly payments. [1] Both are external finance and create regular financial costs or commitments. [1]

(e) A strong choice is to use retained profit and a bank loan for the remaining amount. Using the full $15 000 would require a $33 000 loan. [1] This reduces borrowing and likely interest. [1] The firm would own the machine, [1] which is useful if it will be used for many years. [1]

However, because the manager wants a cash reserve, using only some retained profit and leasing may be better if cash flow is uncertain. [1] Leasing avoids a large immediate purchase cost, although total lease payments may be higher. [1] The final decision should balance ownership and lower borrowing against the need to retain cash for changing timber costs.

Download The App On Google Playstore

Everything you need to excel in your exams

Green Bridge CBT Mobile App
Personalized AI Learning Chat Assistant
200,000+ Exam Questions Across IGCSE, JAMB, WAEC & NECO
Over 3,900 Lesson Notes
Offline Support - Learn Anytime, Anywhere
Green Bridge Timetable
Literature Summaries & Potential Questions
Track Your Performance & Progress
In-depth Explanations for Comprehensive Learning