Question 1 Report
A manufacturer is planning to produce a set of stainless steel kitchen utensils. Each utensil must be cut and shaped accurately from sheet metal. Fig. 31 shows the initial layout of the utensil shapes on the steel sheet.
Use sketches and notes to show how the utensil shapes would be accurately marked out on the stainless steel sheet, ready for cutting. In your answer you should consider:
[25]
[Total: 25 marks]
This extended-response question is assessed using a levels-based mark scheme. A strong answer addresses all six bullet points with detailed, well-annotated sketches and technical notes. The following indicative content outlines the key knowledge expected at the highest level.
Marking-out tools suitable for metal:
Datum edges and their role:
Two adjacent edges of the steel sheet are designated as datum edges (the bottom and left edges in the figure). All measurements are taken from these fixed reference edges. This eliminates cumulative error that would arise if measurements were chained from one marked point to the next. The datum edges must be straight and at 90 degrees to each other; an engineer's square is used to verify this before marking begins.
Templates and jigs for batch production:
For batch quantities, thin sheet-metal or acrylic templates are made for each utensil shape. The template is placed on the steel sheet, clamped in position, and the scriber is drawn around its edge to transfer the outline accurately. Templates eliminate the need to re-measure each shape individually, ensuring every utensil is identical. A jig could also locate the template at the correct position relative to the datum edges, further speeding up the process and reducing errors.
Tolerances and why they matter:
Tolerances define the permitted range of dimensional variation (for example, length +/- 0.5 mm). For kitchen utensils, tight tolerances are important because the handle must fit comfortably in the hand (ergonomic requirement), parts must align with dies or formers used in subsequent shaping operations, and the finished products must look uniform when displayed as a matching set. Exceeding the tolerance would cause rejection at quality control.
Marking hole positions for hanging hooks:
The position of each hole is located by scribing two intersecting lines (one measured from each datum edge). A centre punch is then struck at the intersection to create an indentation that prevents the drill bit from wandering when the hole is drilled. The centre-punched position is checked against the specification using a steel rule before drilling.
Quality control checks before cutting:
Levels-based assessment:
| Level | Marks | Descriptor |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | 21-25 | Excellent: detailed annotated sketches; all six bullet points addressed thoroughly; specific tool names with reasons for suitability; clear datum-edge explanation; templates/jigs described with reasoning; tolerances defined with values linked to function; hole marking with intersecting lines and centre punch; specific, practical QC checks. |
| 4 | 16-20 | Good: clear sketches and notes covering most points in detail; most tools named with suitability explained; datum edges and templates addressed; tolerances mentioned with some explanation; some QC checks identified. |
| 3 | 11-15 | Adequate: recognisable sketches covering at least four points; several tools named; datum edges referenced; some mention of templates or tolerances; basic QC checks suggested. |
| 2 | 6-10 | Basic: simple sketches with limited notes; two or three points addressed superficially; some tools named without full explanation; limited reference to accuracy or quality. |
| 1 | 1-5 | Minimal: incomplete sketches; one or two tools may be named; little or no explanation of accuracy, tolerances, or quality control. |
Everything you need to excel in your exams