Question 1 Report
Fig. 11.1 shows a bar magnet that has been broken into two pieces, P and Q.
(a) State the poles of piece Q from left to right. [1]
(b) State the total number of poles on the two pieces combined. [1]
(c) State whether it is possible to obtain an isolated north pole by breaking a magnet. Explain your answer. [2]
(a) The poles of piece Q from left to right are: N (left) and S (right). [1]
When a magnet is broken, the internal domain alignment is preserved. The original bar had N on the left and S on the right. Piece Q came from the right-hand (S) end of the original bar, but the domains throughout Q still point left-to-right (N to S), so Q has N on its left face and S on its right face.
(b) The total number of poles on the two pieces combined is four (two on each piece). [1]
Piece P has an N pole and an S pole; piece Q also has an N pole and an S pole. Each piece is a complete magnet.
(c) No, it is not possible to obtain an isolated north pole by breaking a magnet. [1]
Every time a magnet is broken, each resulting piece becomes a complete magnet with both a north pole and a south pole. [1] This is because magnetism arises from the alignment of domains (groups of atomic magnetic dipoles). Each domain, no matter how small, has both a north and south end. You cannot separate one pole from the other; magnetic monopoles do not exist. Even if you kept breaking the pieces into smaller and smaller fragments, each fragment would always have two poles.
Everything you need to excel in your exams